gwyn_bywyd: Photo of a yellow orchid. (Orchid)
[personal profile] gwyn_bywyd
I'm more than a little puzzled and irritated at myself with regards to recent news that my mother may have Lupus. Her mother had Lupus. Which has, of course, led to a fresh round of the game "maybe you have xyz not cfs."  (A fun game for all the family to play! Not to mention random strangers!) I'm irritated at myself for engaging in this for a number of reasons, not least that I have been checked for Lupus, at least once a year, since falling ill. Ditto thyroid problems and diabetes.

But I think the biggest irritation is that I am implicitly engaging in a sort "hierarchy of disability" in these discussions. What am I unconsciously implying by participating in this? Is Lupus somehow more "real" than cfs because there are diagnostic tools and it has been recognised for longer? That is something I most emphatically do not believe with my conscious thought-processes, but I'm looking suspiciously sideways at my subconscious. (btw, is there an emoticon for that?)

Something of the same implicit assumptions are present in my feelings about using a wheel-chair. In June I am travelling overseas. Last time I did this it was only an 8 hour flight, (this time it is one 8 hour leg and one 15 hour leg each way) but even so it was so exhausting that I could barely walk off the plane at the other end. It was a horrible, horrible experience. Mostly because of the reaction of my parents. There is no nice way to write this. They were ashamed that I could barely use my legs. In their defence, this was quite early in my illness, and at that point I didn't realise that people with cfs might lose the use of their legs. My parents felt that I wasn't trying hard enough. Long and painful story short, in June I will use a wheel-chair to get through the airport. I probably can walk the distances involved. But standing in a customs queue - potentially for hours - is utterly out of the question. But I am feeling enormous guilt and shame over the idea of using a wheel-chair when I don't need to (ie I am not paralysed), despite the fact I do need to. I have only just started truly self-identifying as disabled. Which is ludicrous, because I've been disabled for years.

Obviously I've internalised a great deal of my parents' shit about "pulling oneself up by one's boot-straps" and "mind over matter." With a nice big helping of crap about what is and isn't a 'real' disability. [I want to emphasise that in people not myself, cfs and all sorts of other invisible disabilities are both consciously and unconsciously very much counted as 'real disabilities' - all this junk seems to only apply to me.]

This sounds unfair to my parents. In fact, they do more in terms of accommodations than many. (My father is a doctor, and accommodations for his patients have always been a priority, and they truly think about what patients need, not just doing the bare minimum of what is required.) But here is where hierarchies of disability come in. I have all my limbs, look healthy, can mostly control my limbs. When I can't, it feels as if they feel I'm putting it on, or not trying hard enough. They have come so very far in four years. But it is still as if I'm not a 'real' disabled person. They make me feel this at the same time as buying me walking sticks and purposefully choosing the most colourful, 'youngest' looking one for me. Honestly, I'm not sure how they're accomplishing these mental gymnastics.

I do also wonder if there is some paternalism and/or othering going on here. People with disabilities are patients, people with disabilities are over there. We'll be very nice to them, and do everything we can to help them, but they are not us. Just to complicate matters is the intense awareness that my parents have that we are in a 'system of limited good' with regard to disability in this country. I have never received the disability pension, because when my GP suggested it, my parents said "There's not enough to go around as it is, we're lucky enough to have the means to support you, that money needs to go to people without that support." And there's a bit of that with me and the wheelchair use. I think "Am I ruining it for people who have no other options if people see a seemingly 'able-bodied' person using a chair? Will it just increase misconceptions about PWD??!! Argh!"

It would seem I am doing those extreme mental gymnastics myself, simultaneously recognising that I am disabled, but feeling guilt over using systems and tools for people with disabilities. It is exhausting, and I don't like what it says about my subconscious beliefs about disability.

(no subject)

Date: 2010-04-12 07:18 am (UTC)
feuille: "an interrobang says what", followed by an interrobang (janeway wins hands down)
From: [personal profile] feuille
I can totally understand worrying about how it seems to other people and not wanting to make a situation worse for other people.

But what you need is what you need, and if you need it you should have it, end of story. It doesn't matter what illness you have or how 'bad' it is, if you need a treatment or support then you should have it.

*hugs* I hope when you do fly it is less exhausting for you!

(no subject)

Date: 2010-04-12 09:15 am (UTC)
From: [personal profile] puzzlement
Aw, sympathy for trained and internalised difficulties. I want to say a few things, but they could be 'splainy, so I'll bring it up in person so you can shut me down more readily if need be.

Meantime, a couple of recs. Are you reading [personal profile] badgerbag or [personal profile] synecdochic? Both are wheelchair users, as it happens, and awesome.
Edited Date: 2010-04-12 09:15 am (UTC)

(no subject)

Date: 2010-04-12 11:11 am (UTC)
lilacsigil: 12 Apostles rocks, text "Rock On" (12 Apostles)
From: [personal profile] lilacsigil
Three things in this post really hit home for me.

I am implicitly engaging in a sort "hierarchy of disability" in these discussions.

I was misdiagnosed with CFS when I actually had thyroid cancer. As soon as it turned out that I had A Thing That Showed Up In Tests, everyone's attitude towards me suddenly changed for the better (and I hated that, and have never spoken to most of them again!) There really is a hierarchy, and I think that you being aware of it is important and relevant. Personally, I was deeply shocked and offended, which was not a very useful reaction! It's hard to throw off these kinds of things, and your awareness of the problem is an important part of the battle.

we're lucky enough to have the means to support you, that money needs to go to people without that support.

See, if this was my parents, I would see this as a means of control, a way to remove self-determination and keep me inside their definitions of sick and well. (They did in fact offer to support me, rather than have me go on the disability pension, but I refused. Then I couldn't get the disability pension because cancer is not disabling enough, but I could get income support.) Not knowing your parents, I can't say the same for them, but this makes me really uncomfortable, personally.

But I am feeling enormous guilt and shame over the idea of using a wheel-chair when I don't need to (ie I am not paralysed), despite the fact I do need to

I have chronic vertigo and it's worst in the mornings. I never, ever thought of getting a device to aid me in picking up my shoes etc. because that was for disabled people. Even after I did realise that something to help me pick things up would be very helpful, I *still* felt uncomfortable about it - but my girlfriend encouraged me and The Claw is the best thing ever. My dizziness is so very much improved and I have more energy just by standing up to my own stupid preconceptions and being "disabled". I'm trying to see it like wearing glasses, or warmer clothes in cold weather - just something that people use to cope with their environment, that not everyone needs.

(no subject)

Date: 2010-04-14 05:36 pm (UTC)
ext_245057: painted half-back picture of me that looks more like me than any photograph (Default)
From: [identity profile]
(If this appears twice in different forms: please delete the other one which wasn't finished!)

When I was seven months pregnant with twins we went on a second-hand-bookshop spree with friends. One of them, who happened to be a nurse, borrowed a wheelchair for me because, though I could walk at a normal pace for quite some distance, all the accoutrements of book-browsing were difficult to impossible: standing still for more than a minute or so, moving slowly, stopping and starting.

It was a great idea. Also a very interesting learning experience: to be on the receiving end of preconceptions against people with a wheelchair. The most priceless was the series of looks on the face of people who saw me being pushed into their shop or cafe, jump out of the chair, then turn so they could see my whale-shaped profile.

I agree with feuille (could someone please tell me how to get a link to someone?) that if you need it you should have it. Also with lilacsigil that it's a way to cope with your environment: your particular environment includes the fact that planes are more tiring for you than for the average person, so you need and deserve additional comfort to even it out.


gwyn_bywyd: Photo of a yellow orchid. (Default)

May 2010

91011 12131415
23242526 272829

Most Popular Tags

Style Credit

Expand Cut Tags

No cut tags
Powered by Dreamwidth Studios